October 29, 2026
Anna Caragiulo is 87 and sewed the curtains herself. They are gold and hang 14.5 feet in the new Caragiulos dining room on Ringling Boulevard. Her son Paul told Sarasota Magazine that they also improve the acoustics for the vinyl records he plays there. The restaurant was scheduled to open to the public on Tuesday, Oct. 27, almost a year after its last meal on Palm Avenue.
A year ago a homemade detail like those curtains might have looked like the end of an era for downtown. Now it fits a pattern. September and October emptied some of downtown Sarasota's best-known rooms, and each one is being refilled by someone already cooking in Sarasota. The national chains that came to town this fall opened at University Town Center.
Tony Caragiulo and his sons John, Mark, Rob, Anthony and Paul opened Caragiulos at 69 S. Palm Ave. in 1989. In 2025 Paul told Sarasota Magazine that it started out as "a meatball hero and Styrofoam cup kind of place." The lease there ran through 2040. In 2023 the Mira Mar property sold to Seaward Development for $17.3 million while that lease was still in effect. Seaward then won approval to restore the historic Palm Avenue frontage and build two 18-story condominium towers behind it. Caragiulos closed in October 2025 with about 15 years left on the lease.
The new place is at 1833 Ringling Blvd., on land owned by the same man who sold the Mira Mar, Dr. Mark Kauffmann. The building is about 4,300 square feet with 150 seats, a full bar and a covered patio. The family saved the marble from the old Palm Avenue bar, cut it into strips and set it into the new one. Artwork and original Italian film posters made the move too. The Herald-Tribune reported an invitation-only preview on Oct. 14.
The menu shows the move in prices. These figures come from the menu posted online before opening:
| Dish | Status | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Pasolini with Gorgonzola cream and sun-dried tomatoes | Returning favorite | $23 |
| Meatballs | Returning favorite | $21 |
| 37-layer lasagna | Returning favorite | $25 |
| Pizzette | Returning favorite | $14 to $15.95 |
| Spaghettini with Cedar Key clams | New | $26 |
| King crab cappellacci | New | $37 |
| Halibut cacciucco with mussels and prawns | New | $43 |
| 40 oz. bone-in bistecca Fiorentina, with two sides | New | $115 |
The lasagna is still on the menu. The $115 steak is the change, and Sarasota Magazine reports that many longtime employees are expected back after working at the family's other restaurants during the closure. Hours and reservation details are on caragiulos.com.
The Caragiulos move was planned years ahead. The next change came fast. On Sept. 15, chef and owner Steve Phelps announced that Indigenous had closed after 15 years in its cottage downtown. The Herald-Tribune called it one of the biggest losses in a busy month of openings and closings.
A new tenant was lined up within days. On Sept. 18 the Herald-Tribune reported that Alma de España chef and owner Elier Rodriguez planned to move from 1830 S. Osprey Ave. in Southside Village into the cottage at 239 S. Links Ave. Alma had opened in Southside Village only the year before. It is a Spanish tapas and wood-fired grill concept, so a restaurant that is about a year old now takes over a room that one chef held for 15 years. Alma's own site lists the Links Avenue address and a grand opening this Sunday, Nov. 1, 2026.
So both of the season's biggest downtown openings use rooms with a history. Caragiulos built a new building and furnished it with pieces of the old one. Alma moves into an existing building that already has a following.
At 1660 Main St., the old and new restaurants share owners. The Herald-Tribune reported on Oct. 11 that Lucile Pizza & Wine Bar had closed. Its owners, Ryan Boeve and Mark Baldwin, are replacing it with Mitchell's Food and Wine in the same space. The new restaurant's reservation listing describes contemporary New American food with Neapolitan-style pizza. It shows dinner Tuesday through Saturday, 4:30 to 9 p.m., with takeout on Sundays and Mondays. The first available reservation date listed was Saturday, Oct. 24. Lucile's regulars will find the same owners and the same pizza oven tradition under a new name.
New names did arrive downtown in September, and they took open storefronts on Main Street and Ringling Boulevard:
The out-of-town brands landed elsewhere. In the same Herald-Tribune roundup, Just Salad, a New York City chain, opened its first Sarasota-area location at University Town Center. A sign at UTC suggests Hawkers Asian Street Food is coming soon, and Grimaldi's Pizzeria named Sarasota County in a Southwest Florida expansion. The main downtown exception is 1000 North, a restaurant and private club first opened in Palm Beach County. The same roundup reported its downtown Sarasota project was delayed at a city planning meeting over resident and parking concerns.
Not every closing has a replacement lined up. Sarasota Magazine reported that Artisan Cheese Company has closed after 14 and a half years in business. Owner Louise Converse opened it at 1310 Main St. in 2012 and moved it to 550 Central Ave. in the Rosemary District in 2018. Indigenous and Artisan Cheese had run a combined 29 years downtown. Only one of their spaces has a known next tenant so far.
Here is the fall map as dates you can use this week. Two of them overlap with events that were already on downtown's calendar:
| Date | Where | What |
|---|---|---|
| Tue., Oct. 27 | 1833 Ringling Blvd. | Caragiulos public opening date |
| Tue. to Sat., 4:30 to 9 p.m. | 1660 Main St. | Mitchell's Food and Wine dinner service, per its reservation listing |
| Through Sun., Nov. 1 | The Bay | One Park FOUR All 4th Anniversary Community Celebration |
| Sun., Nov. 1 | 239 S. Links Ave. | Alma de España grand opening |
| Through Dec. 6 | Selby Gardens, Downtown Sarasota campus | The Orchid Show 2026: Christian Sampson |
The anniversary programming at The Bay runs through Nov. 1, the same day Alma opens on Links Avenue. That makes it easy to pair a walk along the water with a tapas dinner. Selby Gardens has its holiday light show, Lights in Bloom, on the calendar from Dec. 5 to Jan. 2, 2027. That gives the new dining rooms about a month to settle in before the holiday crowds arrive downtown.
Restaurant openings like these change how a block feels day to day, and that often decides which downtown street people want to live near. If you're wondering what living within walking distance of Ringling Boulevard, Main Street or Links Avenue adds to your property's value, Christine Walker can give you a fast, local answer. Start with your instant home valuation.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Real Estate
Real Estate
Get assistance in determining current property value, crafting a competitive offer, writing and negotiating a contract, and much more. Contact me today.